Earlier this offseason, CHONE and Baseball Prospectus released their projected standings for the 2010 MLB regular season, and both have the Twins winning the division.
CHONE and Baseball Prospectus are just two of many projection systems, but they tend to be the most credible from year to year. Baseball Prospectus famously predicted the Rays’ rise to relevance before the 2008 season when hardly anybody else had them on the radar.
In 2009, CHONE had the Yankees, Indians and Angels winning their respective American League divisions, with the Red Sox earning a wild card berth. CHONE also had the Phillies, Cubs and Dodgers winning the NL divisions, with the Braves earning the wild card.
CHONE obviously whiffed on the Twins and Cardinals last year, who both won their divisions, but it nailed the Braves, who won 86 games (even though Atlanta missed the playoffs). Colorado wound up catching fire and earning the NL wild card slot.
Now, obviously, projecting baseball standings can be an inexact science, because injuries and various unforeseen productivity issues almost always pop up. But ultimately, CHONE and Baseball Prospectus are pretty solid over the long run. That said, a team like Colorado or Minnesota will sneak out a few extra wins from time to time.
With all of that said, here’s what CHONE and Baseball Prospectus predict for the 2010 season:
CHONE
AL East: Yankees (96 wins)
AL Central: Twins (85 wins)
AL West: Rangers (86 wins)
AL wild card: Red Sox (93 wins)
NL East: Braves (89 wins)
NL Central: Cardinals (91 wins)
NL West: Dodgers/Rockies tie (83 wins)
NL wild card: Phillies (87 wins)
* CHONE also has the White Sox and the Tigers finishing below .500, with the Indians finishing 2nd in the AL Central at 81-81. The Rays are slated to win 88 games, but miss the playoffs.
Baseball Prospectus
AL East: Red Sox (96 wins)
AL Central: Twins (81 wins)
AL West: Rangers/A’s tie (83 wins)
AL wild card: Yankees/Rays tie (91 wins)
NL East: Phillies (90 wins)
NL Central: Cardinals (88 wins)
NL West: Rockies (86 wins)
NL wild card: Braves (86 wins)
* Prospectus clearly sees the American League as very “middle of the road.” In fact, these are all very conservative predictions for some reason. The biggest surprise is probably the A’s emerging as AL West contenders.
My Predictions
AL East: Yankees (96 wins)
The AL East, once again, will house three of the best teams in baseball between the Yankees, Red Sox and Rays. These are all playoff-worthy teams, but the Yankees have “mystique,” cool pinstripes, and Derek Jeter. So I’ll pick them.
AL Central: Twins (89 wins)
The reason CHONE and Baseball Prospectus have the Twins winning only 85 and/or 81 games (but still winning the division) is because they probably don’t trust the starting pitching. Valid argument, but I firmly believe Francisco Liriano, Scott Baker and Kevin Slowey are in line for very solid seasons. Call me an optimist. The lineup speaks for itself.
AL West: Rangers (86 wins)
Seattle is the team to watch for the next few years, but the Rangers look like the team to beat in 2010. Texas’ offense will certainly mash, assuming Josh Hamilton, Ian Kinsler (who will miss most of April) and Nelson Cruz stay healthy. Also watch out for potential young studs 1B Chris Davis, SS Elvis Andrus, and CF Julio Borbon. The starting pitching after Rich Harden leaves a little something to be desired, but scoring 800+ runs on offense should help.
AL wild card: Rays (90 wins)
The Red Sox will be awesome too, but I have a sneaky feeling about the Rays. They play fantastic defense, draw a ton of walks, hit for a ton of power, and have some lively young arms. The Rays’ chances of outlasting Boston and/or New York likely rides on how well David Price, Wade Davis, and Rafael Soriano can pitch. I love all three.
NL East: Braves (87 wins)
The Phillies’ bullpen and bottom of the rotation make me nervous. Roy Halladay and Cole Hamels will keep Philly in contention all year, along with one of the better lineups in baseball, but the Braves are the under-the-radar team to watch here. With SP Tommy Hanson and OF Jason Heyward, Atlanta has the 2nd-best pitching prospect and top hitting prospect ready to roll from opening day. A memorable send-off for Bobby Cox?
NL Central: Cardinals (90 wins)
The gambler in me wants to pick the Cubs, but with Chris Carpenter and Adam Wainwright spinning gems at the top of the rotation, St. Louis is a tough beat. Not to mention a heart of the lineup that includes Albert Pujols, Matt Holliday, Colby Rasmus and Ryan Ludwick — easily 110-130 HRs right there. Not to mention, the Cardinals’ bullpen leads the majors in “beard thickness”…
NL West: Rockies (86 wins)
Is there a more anonymous team in baseball than the Colorado Rockies? A far cry from the mid-90′s days of Dante Bichette, Andres Gallarraga, Larry Walker, etc. The difference here, besides a humidor and fewer moon shots, is pitching. The Rockies’ pitching staff finished 5th in the league last year in FIP (Fielding Independent Pitching, similar to ERA), and they allowed the 5th-fewest amount of home runs. Missing Huston Street for a month (shoulder) will hurt, but the Rockies will score a ton of runs anyways.
NL wild card: Phillies (86 wins)
The Dodgers, Marlins, Cubs and Giants should hang around deep into the season, but the Phillies have too much offensive firepower to go along with Halladay and Hamels. Would love to see what they can do in the playoffs once again.